- Nikita Hora
Can a civil suit be rejected merely because the document relied upon is unregistered? – Hon’ble Supreme Court clarifies the law.

The Supreme Court of India, in a recent judgment[1], has examined whether a plaint can be rejected under Order VII Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC), merely because the document relied upon by the plaintiff is unregistered and allegedly inadmissible in evidence. The Court clarified that such questions of admissibility should ordinarily be decided during the trial and not at the preliminary stage of deciding an application for rejection of the plaint.
The dispute arose out of a lease arrangement between the parties involving a plot of land. The parties had initially executed a registered lease deed dated 17 October 2011 for a period of 33 years. Subsequently, on 15 February 2013, they executed a supplementary lease deed modifying certain terms and conditions of the original lease, including the rent payable. However, the supplementary lease deed was not registered.
When the defendants allegedly failed to pay rent in accordance with the revised terms, the plaintiffs terminated the lease and filed a suit seeking eviction and recovery of outstanding rent.
The defendants applied for rejection of the plaint under Order VII Rule 11(a) and (d) of the CPC. They argued that the supplementary lease deed was unregistered and, therefore, could not be relied upon in view of Section 49 of the Registration Act, 1908. According to them, since the plaintiffs' claim was based on an inadmissible document, the plaint did not disclose a valid cause of action and was barred by law.
While the Trial Court rejected the defendants' application, the Patna High Court interfered with that decision and directed the Trial Court to reconsider the application without taking the unregistered supplementary lease deed into account. Aggrieved by this decision, the plaintiffs approached the Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court set aside the High Court's order and clarified that the question of whether the supplementary lease deed was admissible in evidence could not be decided while considering an application for rejection of the plaint under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC.
The Court explained that, while deciding an application under Order VII Rule 11, the court must examine the plaint as a whole, along with the documents filed with it. At this stage, the court is required to proceed on the assumption that the statements made in the plaint are correct. The defence raised by the defendant cannot ordinarily be relied upon to determine whether the plaint should be rejected.
The Court further emphasised that rejection of a plaint is a serious step as it brings the proceedings to an end without giving the plaintiff an opportunity to establish its case through evidence. Consequently, this power must be exercised only when the conditions prescribed under Order VII Rule 11 are clearly satisfied.
Importantly, where a plaintiff relies upon an unregistered document, questions such as whether the document requires registration, whether it can be admitted in evidence and whether it can be relied upon for a collateral purpose under the proviso to Section 49 of the Registration Act are matters that may require examination during the trial. The parties must be given an opportunity to present their respective cases before such questions are decided.
Section 49 of the Registration Act provides that a document which is required to be registered but is not registered cannot ordinarily affect the immovable property comprised in it or be received as evidence of a transaction affecting such property. However, the proviso to Section 49 permits certain unregistered documents to be received as evidence of a collateral transaction which is not required to be effected through a registered instrument. Whether a particular document can be relied upon under this exception depends on the nature and purpose for which it is sought to be used.
It is important to note that the Supreme Court did not hold that the supplementary lease deed in the present case was valid or that it was exempt from registration. The Court left the question of its admissibility open for the Trial Court to decide on the merits of the case. The judgment, therefore, does not dilute the statutory requirement of registration under the Registration Act.
The judgment reinforces an important distinction between the maintainability of a suit and the admissibility of the evidence relied upon to prove the plaintiff's case. While a court may ultimately decide that an unregistered document cannot be relied upon for the purpose for which it is produced, that determination should not ordinarily be made prematurely at the stage of an application under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC.