Supreme Court Reconsiders Key PMLA Questions

The Supreme Court's decision to reconstitute the Bench hearing the review petitions arising out of Vijay Madanlal Choudhary v. Union of India marks an important development in the continuing judicial scrutiny of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 (PMLA). On 20 August 2026, the Supreme Court constituted a fresh three-judge Bench comprising the Chief Justice of India, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V. Mohana to hear the pending review proceedings challenging the landmark judgment delivered in July 2022.
The development is significant as the 2022 judgment upheld several provisions of the PMLA governing the powers of the Directorate of Enforcement (ED), including its powers of investigation, arrest and attachment. The review proceedings bring into focus two particularly contentious issues: the non-supply of the Enforcement Case Information Report (ECIR) and the reverse burden of proof under Section 24 of the PMLA.
The 2022 Judgment and the ECIR
In its judgment dated 27 July 2022, the Supreme Court rejected several constitutional challenges to the PMLA. Among its significant findings was that an ECIR is an internal document of the ED and cannot be equated with a First Information Report (FIR) under the Code of Criminal Procedure.
The Court held that furnishing a copy of the ECIR to every person concerned is not mandatory, provided that the grounds of arrest are contemporaneously communicated to the person arrested, in compliance with Section 19 of the PMLA.
The Court reasoned that mandatory disclosure of the ECIR could potentially prejudice an ongoing investigation, particularly where the document contains material concerning the suspected proceeds of crime and persons connected with the alleged money-laundering activity.
Consequently, non-supply of the ECIR, by itself, was held not to constitute a violation of the constitutional rights of the person concerned. The Court also recognised that the Special Court could examine relevant records produced by the ED while considering the necessity of continued detention.
Reverse Burden of Proof Under Section 24
The second significant issue concerns Section 24 of the PMLA, which provides for a statutory presumption concerning proceeds of crime.
The provision departs from the conventional principle governing the burden of proof in criminal proceedings. Under Section 24(a), where proceedings relating to money-laundering are concerned, the Authority or Court shall presume that such proceeds of crime are involved in money-laundering, unless the contrary is proved. Section 24(b), dealing with any other person, uses the expression "may presume".
The distinction between these two clauses is important, as the statutory presumption does not operate identically in respect of every person. Its application is governed by the specific language and conditions prescribed under the provision.
The challenge to Section 24 raises important questions concerning the extent to which the burden of proof can be shifted to an accused person and whether the statutory presumption adequately safeguards the constitutional guarantee of a fair procedure.
The review proceedings therefore assume particular importance for persons facing prosecution under the PMLA, particularly where the evidentiary burden and statutory presumptions become central to the prosecution.
Implications for Pending PMLA Proceedings
The reconstitution of the Bench does not, by itself, alter the legal position established by the 2022 judgment. Until the Supreme Court pronounces its decision in the review proceedings, the findings in Vijay Madanlal Choudhary continue to remain binding.
Nevertheless, the proceedings warrant close attention. Any reconsideration of the legal position concerning ECIR disclosure or the reverse burden under Section 24 could have significant implications for ongoing investigations, bail proceedings and prosecutions under the PMLA.
For practitioners, this development is particularly relevant as it brings renewed attention to the balance between the enforcement objectives of the PMLA and the fundamental rights of persons subjected to proceedings under the legislation.
The outcome of the review proceedings may prove significant in determining the extent of procedural safeguards available to accused persons and the manner in which certain stringent provisions of the PMLA are to be interpreted and applied.
For now, the 2022 judgment continues to govern. The legal position will change only if and to the extent that the Supreme Court modifies its earlier findings in the pending review proceedings.