Back

Late Arbitral Awards: Supreme Court Says the Clock Can Still Be Reset

Blog Post Thumbnail

On 28 October 2026, the Supreme Court in South Bihar Power Distribution Company Ltd. v. India Power Corporation Ltd. (2026 INSC 1165) settled three questions that come up often in Indian arbitrations. First, an arbitrator's time to decide a case can be extended even after that time has run out, and even after an award has been passed in the meantime. Second, only the court defined in Section 2(1)(e) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 can grant that extension. A High Court does not get that power simply because it appointed the arbitrator under Section 11. Third, a party that takes part in proceedings before a sole arbitrator without objecting cannot later insist that the contract called for three arbitrators.

The judgment was delivered by Justice Ujjal Bhuyan and Justice Atul S. Chandurkar. It is a short, practical ruling and it removes a procedural trap that has caught many parties since the time limits were introduced in 2015.

The time limit in plain terms

Section 29A was added to the Act in 2015 to stop arbitrations from dragging on for years. An arbitrator must pass the award within twelve months from the date the pleadings are complete. The parties can agree to add six more months. After that, the arbitrator's authority ends unless a court extends it.

The court can extend the time either before or after the period has run out. It can impose conditions, cut the arbitrator's fees if the delay is the arbitrator's fault, and even replace the arbitrator. An extension is not automatic; the party asking for it must show good reason.

The trouble in practice has been twofold. Parties have not been sure which court to approach, and they have not been sure whether an application filed after the deadline, or after an award was already passed, could be entertained at all. This judgment answers both.

The dispute

The case arose from a Distribution Franchisee Agreement dated 31 December 2013 between South Bihar Power Distribution Company Ltd., India Power Corporation Ltd. and a special purpose company set up to run the franchise, India Power Corporation (Bodhgaya) Ltd., later renamed Vikriti Power Ltd. The agreement provided for a tribunal of three arbitrators.

When disputes arose, the Patna High Court in 2018 appointed a sole arbitrator with the consent of the parties. That arbitrator could not continue, and in 2021 the High Court appointed a replacement, again with consent. South Bihar Power took part in the proceedings and filed counterclaims. The special purpose company was by then in insolvency, and a moratorium under Section 14 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 was in force.

The twelve months and the further six months ran out before the award was ready. India Power and the special purpose company asked the Patna High Court to extend the arbitrator's time. South Bihar Power objected on three grounds: that the contract required three arbitrators and not one; that the High Court had no power to extend time under Section 29A; and that the moratorium barred the special purpose company from pursuing its claim. On 15 September 2023 the High Court rejected all three objections and extended the time by four months. South Bihar Power appealed to the Supreme Court.

In February 2024 the Supreme Court let the arbitration continue but directed that no award be declared until the appeal was decided. In March 2026, on the Supreme Court's directions, the Commercial Court at Patna extended the arbitrator's time by a further six months.

What the Court decided

A late application is still a valid application. The Court held that an application under Section 29A(5) can be filed even after the twelve and eighteen month periods have ended, and even if the arbitrator has already passed an award during that time. Section 29A(4) itself says the court may extend time "either prior to or after the expiry" of the period. Reading in a cut-off that Parliament did not write would force parties to start the whole arbitration again, which is the opposite of what the provision was meant to achieve. The Court followed its earlier rulings in Rohan Builders (India) Pvt. Ltd. v. Berger Paints India Ltd. and M. Velusamy v. Indhera. An award passed after the time has expired is not a nullity; it simply cannot be enforced unless and until the court extends the time. If the court does extend it, the arbitrator picks up from where the mandate lapsed rather than beginning afresh.

Objection to a sole arbitrator was waived. South Bihar Power had agreed to the appointment of a sole arbitrator in 2018 and again in 2021, had appeared before him and had filed counterclaims. Having done all that, it could not raise the three-member clause years later when the time came to extend the mandate. The Court treated this as a clear case of waiver by conduct.

Moratorium does not stop the corporate debtor's own claim. Section 14 of the IBC protects a company in insolvency from claims made against it. It does not stop that company from pursuing money owed to it. The special purpose company was therefore free to continue the arbitration to recover its dues.

Which court can extend the time

This is where the Patna High Court went wrong, and where the Supreme Court set its order aside. The High Court had reasoned that because it appointed the arbitrator under Section 11, it could also extend his time under Section 29A. The Supreme Court disagreed.

Section 29A gives the power of extension to the "court". That word is defined in Section 2(1)(e). For a domestic arbitration it means the principal civil court of original jurisdiction in the district, which in most commercial matters is the Commercial Court, or a High Court that has ordinary original civil jurisdiction, such as the Bombay, Delhi, Calcutta and Madras High Courts. A High Court acting under Section 11 is doing something different. It is appointing an arbitrator under a power that is separate from, and ends with, the appointment. It does not carry on supervising the arbitration afterwards. The Court followed its own earlier decisions in Chief Engineer (NH) PWD (Roads) v. BSC & C and C JV and Jagdeep Chowgule v. Seema Chowgule on this point.

The practical result is that in a State like Bihar, where the High Court has no original civil jurisdiction, an application to extend the arbitrator's time goes to the District or Commercial Court, even though the High Court made the appointment. In Mumbai, by contrast, the Bombay High Court on its original side is the Section 2(1)(e) court for matters above its pecuniary threshold, so the application is filed there.

What this means for parties

The appeals were dismissed without costs. The Supreme Court lifted its earlier restraint and directed the arbitrator to pronounce the award within six weeks of 28 October 2026.

For parties in a running arbitration, the lessons are simple. Keep a diary of the Section 29A dates from the day pleadings close. If the award is not going to be ready in time, apply for an extension before the period ends, because a court is more likely to grant it, and on better terms, when the delay has been flagged early. If the period has already lapsed, or an award has already come out, the door is not shut. File the application; the court will decide it on merits.

File it in the right court. In most of the country that is the District or Commercial Court, not the High Court that appointed the arbitrator. An application filed in the wrong court costs time and, as this case shows, can take years to correct.

Raise objections to the composition of the tribunal at the start or not at all. A party that accepts a sole arbitrator, appears before him and files counterclaims will be held to that choice.

Finally, a company in insolvency can still pursue its own claims in arbitration. The moratorium is a shield for the company, not a bar on it recovering what it is owed.