When “Final” Is Not the Final Word : Supreme Court on Unilateral Decisions in State Contracts

By Aman Arora, Associate Partner, Desai & Diwanji 03 November 2026
Imagine signing a contract with a government body where the government alone decides whether you breached the contract, how much you owe, and then tells you that you cannot take that decision to any court or arbitrator. That is the situation the Supreme Court of India recently addressed in ABS Marine Services v. Andaman and Nicobar Administration.
The Story Behind the Dispute
ABS Marine Services had entered into a manning agreement with the Andaman and Nicobar Administration to provide officers for seventeen vessels. The agreement ran for one year. A separate technical manager was responsible for the actual operation of the ships.
One of the vessels, while sailing through rough seas, hit a submerged rock and suffered damage. The Administration later issued a show cause notice to ABS Marine, alleged negligence, and unilaterally recovered nearly Rs. 2.88 crore from the company's pending bills as a penalty for the grounding.
ABS Marine disputed the allegation of negligence. The matter went to arbitration. The arbitrator found in favour of ABS Marine and ordered the Administration to return the recovered amount with interest. The District Judge upheld that award. But the High Court set the award aside, holding that the dispute fell outside the arbitrator's authority because of a specific clause in the contract.
The Clause That Caused All the Trouble
The contract contained two clauses that sat in tension with each other. One clause, dealing with defaults, said that where the manning agent's wilful act or negligence caused financial loss, the Administration could recover the loss from amounts due to the agent. It went on to say that the Administration's decision would be final and binding, could not be challenged in any court of law, and that no arbitration proceedings would lie on this account.
The other clause was a standard arbitration clause. It said that any dispute arising out of the agreement that could not be settled amicably would be referred to a sole arbitrator. On its face, this covered all disputes between the parties.
The Administration's argument was straightforward: the default clause carves out these recovery disputes from arbitration, and the Administration's own decision on whether the agent was negligent is final. The arbitrator therefore had no business adjudicating the matter at all.
What the Supreme Court Held
The Supreme Court rejected the Administration's position and restored the arbitral award in favour of ABS Marine. Its reasoning rests on three principles that are important for any business contracting with the government to understand.
First, one party to a contract cannot be the judge of its own claim. When the manning agent disputed that it was negligent, the question of whether negligence occurred at all had to be decided by an independent forum. Allowing the Administration, which was the party alleging the breach, to also decide whether the breach happened would go against the most basic idea of fairness. The Court said that the finality attached to the Administration's decision under the default clause can only apply to the quantification of loss in a case where the agent admits liability. Where liability itself is disputed, the Administration does not get the last word.
Second, a contract cannot create a situation where a party has no remedy at all. The default clause, as read by the Administration, would bar access to both courts and arbitration. That would leave the manning agent with nowhere to go if it disagreed with the Administration's unilateral decision. The Court found this unacceptable, invoking the principle that there must be a remedy for every wrong.
Third, the arbitration clause was broadly worded and covered all disputes arising out of the agreement. A dispute about whether the manning agent was wilful or negligent is a dispute arising out of the agreement. Reading the default clause to shut out arbitration would make the arbitration clause meaningless. The two clauses had to be read together, and when they are, the only matters genuinely kept out of arbitration are cases where the agent admits fault and only wants to question the amount fixed by the Administration.
The Wider Message for Government Contracts
The Court made a point of saying that clauses of this kind should not find their way into contracts between the government and private parties. It is one thing to carve out certain matters from arbitration; that is a recognised practice. But it is quite another to exclude arbitration and simultaneously block access to courts, leaving a private party with no forum at all. The Court was blunt in calling such clauses grossly discriminatory.
The Court also noted an internal contradiction in the default clause itself. Even where the agent admits liability, if the amounts recoverable from the agent exceed what the Administration holds, the clause says the Administration can initiate proceedings to recover the difference. So the Administration reserves for itself the right to go to court when it suits its interests, while denying the other party the same access. This one-sided design did not sit well with the Court.
What This Means In Practice
A government body that is a party to a contract cannot reserve to itself the power to decide whether the other party was at fault when that party disputes the claim. An independent forum must decide questions of liability. The Supreme Court has openly discouraged government bodies from inserting clauses that deny private parties access to any forum while preserving their own right to initiate recovery proceedings. Businesses entering government contracts should scrutinise any clause that makes the government's decision final and unchallengeable, and should negotiate to keep disputes about liability within the arbitration framework.